Push to ban underquoting

Push to ban underquoting

18 June 2014 by Miriam Sandkuhler 5 comments

Momentum is gathering across Victoria and NSW to put a stop to the deceptive practice of underquoting.

There are now two petitions on change.org seeking input from each respective state government to intervene to stamp out this unscrupulous method of selling real estate. (Victorian petition here and NSW petition here)

In spite of being a breach of regulation in Victoria, the old school practice of ‘quote it low and watch it go’ is well and truly operating. And it is often to the detriment of the vendor as well as the buyers. When an auction fails and the property passes in, the market is well and truly saying they don’t agree with the vendor’s reserve price on the day. Had there been pricing transparency from the beginning, the ‘right’ buyers could have attended and competed to buy.

In addition, there are many estate agents who do adhere to regulations and pricing guidelines. However, those that don’t create an uneven playing field, often forcing those who would rather not, to play the same dirty game. They often can’t compete with underquoting agents when they do the right thing. For example, if two agents each have a similar property listed for sale but one agent is quoting $75,000 less than the other, then of course the (perceived) ‘cheaper’ property will generate more interest, enquiry and prospective bidders on auction day.

Some agents argue that it’s the buyer's responsibility to know market prices. However, when many agencies list properties on websites with no price disclosed (POA) and at times no address either, it forces buyers to frequently enquire about property that may not be in their price range. While agents love this because it generates enquiry, where they let themselves down is by underquoting to the point where they can’t handle the volume of ‘false’ enquiries they receive and they ‘burn’ buyers by not getting back to them or not having adequate information to assist when they make the enquiry. This happens in Victoria where they rush to put a listing to market and advertise it, but often don’t have pertinent information such as a contract, Section 32 or even the land size of the property for weeks and sometime a day or two before the actual auction, again ‘burning’ buyers in the process. 

As a professional buyer's agent, I am sadly surprised more often than not when an agent responds to my enquiry in a prompt manner and more surprised when they can answer all of my questions regarding the property. As a buyer (agent) it’s quite frustrating and while I understand this is one of the reasons why clients engage my services, it doesn’t lend the industry to being seen as very professional.

The introduction of new legislation to compel a vendor’s reserve price to be declared in writing across all marketing materials (print and electronic) from the commencement of the marketing campaign, will lead to greater transparency and will ensure all agents are actually following the same set of rules.

This new legislation would enable buyers to be informed about whether or not they wish to proceed with investing time, emotion, energy and money into potentially purchasing the property. It will also ensure for vendors, that genuine buyers attend the auction, reducing the reliance upon despised ‘vendor’ bids to create momentum before or during an auction, while also reducing the chance of the property being passed in at auction.

Let’s hope the government agrees!

Miriam Sandkuhler is the founder of Property Mavens - a specialist property advisory firm based in Melbourne.

Unlike most ‘Property Advisors’, Miriam is an Accredited Property Investment Advisor (PIAA), Licensed Estate Agent and REIV member and award nominated Buyer Agent, with fourteen years of real estate experience in two states. She is also the author of the book Property Prosperity.

Miriam excels at identifying high-performing property and strategically building a client’s portfolio with high capital and income growth assets. She is also a passionate advocate of fair play for all and complete accountability and transparency in the real estate industry. She has a strong track record helping investors and home buyers and believes education is the key to empowering people on their journey to achieving their goals.

promoted content
Recommended by Spike Native Network
reb top 100 agents 2016

With a combined sales volume of $13 billion in 2016, the Top 100 Agents ranking represents the very best sales agents in Australia. Find out what sets them apart and learn their secrets to success.

featured podcast

featured podcast
At the top of his game: how this agent evolves to stay number one

Get up close and personal with the best real estate sales agents in Australia in Secrets of the Top 100 Agents. ...

View all podcasts

Are dodgy agents being punished enough?

Yes (8.6%)
No (55%)
Only in some states (2.3%)
Not all dodgy agents are being found out (34.1%)

Total votes: 220
The voting for this poll has ended on: April 15, 2017
upcoming events
REB Awards
Sydney The Event Centre 12 Sep
REB Awards
Sydney The Event Centre 12 Sep
Melbourne The Event Centre 14 Oct
Brisbane The Event Centre 18 Dec
View all events
Do you have an industry update?