Ensure you never miss an issue of the
real estate business bulletin
Criminal tenant successfully appeals eviction

Criminal tenant successfully appeals eviction

by Staff Reporter 0 comments

A dispute between a tenant and the state Land and Housing Corporation has ended up in the Court of Appeal, and may set a new precedent for removing tenants with ‘behavioural’ problems.

The tenant was convicted of cultivation and supply of cannabis, after which the landlord (NSW Land and Housing Corporation) sought to terminate the lease under section 91 of the Residential Tenancies Act.

This would permit the tribunal to issue a termination order if the tenant uses the premises for the manufacture, sale, cultivation or supply of a prohibited drug.

However, the tenant argued that despite 12 kilograms of marijuana being found at the premises, there was no evidence the tenant used the premises for the manufacture, sale, cultivation or supply of cannabis.

The tribunal did not grant the termination order, but instead ordered the tenant not to permit the premises to be used for any illegal purpose, and gave the landlord the option to have the matter re-heard if the tenant did not comply with that order.

The tribunal's decision was overturned at the district court, but reinstated at the Court of Appeal.

The Court of Appeal found that the tribunal had discretion as to whether to issue the termination order or not.

The reasons the tribunal exercised its discretion in favour of the tenant included:

  • the tenant's history of illness and mental illness;
  • the tenant's history of drug abuse;
  • the tenant's undertaking (as part of her bail conditions) to reside in the premises; and
  • to give the tenant an opportunity to show she could complete her medical treatment and rehabilitation program.

The case has demonstrated the difficulty any landlord can have in evicting tenants due to behaviour - even when the behaviour is criminal.

Criminal tenant successfully appeals eviction
lawyersweekly logo
promoted content
Recommended by Spike Native Network
Listen to other installment of the Real Estate Business Podcast
reb top 100 agents 2017

The REB Top 100 Agents ranking is the foremost ranking of agents in Australia. It has set the bar for excellence in Australian real estate. To be ranked as an REB Top 100 Agent is the standard real estate professionals strive for. See the full 2018 ranking here!

featured podcast

featured podcast
An industry where the resilient succeeds

Tim Heavyside believes that a strong support team and good foundations are paramount to success in the real estate industry, and with regu...

View all podcasts

Would you consider working for Purplebricks or a similar 'DIY' model?

Yes (7.2%)
No (80.9%)
Perhaps - make me an offer (12%)

Total votes: 209
The voting for this poll has ended on: July 13, 2018
Do you have an industry update?