Powered by MOMENTUM MEDIA
realestatebusiness logo
Subscribe to our newsletter SIGN UP

Scrapping negative gearing not on the agenda

18 March 2015 Elyse Perrau

Both sides of politics are committed to retaining negative gearing, a senior federal politician has revealed.

Shadow Treasurer Chris Bowen, speaking on ABC television, said the possibility of negative gearing being scrapped was a discussion the nation needed to have.

“There is a real housing affordability problem in Australia and we need to look at all the options on the table,” Mr Bowen said.

“[However], I don’t think either side of politics is going to abolish negative gearing tomorrow.”

Treasurer Joe Hockey said it was a cheap shot to say politicians didn't want to abolish negative gearing because they owned too many investment properties. 

“The main issue about negative gearing is this: if you abolish negative gearing on investment properties, there’s a strong argument that rents would increase,” Mr Hockey said on ABC television. 

“If you could see some evidence to say that you would not see any increase in rents if you abolish negative gearing there might be a more compelling case, but I don’t see that.”

However, Grattan Institute chief executive John Daley said the evidence shows rents did not rise everywhere when negative gearing was abolished during 1985-1987. 

“You look beyond Sydney and the answer is rents barely moved in Brisbane, didn’t go up very far in Melbourne, didn’t go up very far in Adelaide,” Mr Daley said. 

“They did go up very fast in Perth, which makes you suspect very strongly that that race memory we have of ‘abolish negative gearing and rents will go up’ is a race memory built on Sydney.” 

Economic theory suggests the abolition of negative gearing should not lead to higher rents, Mr Daley said.

“What happens at the auction is that the investor doesn’t win the auction, but someone who wants to live in the house does,” he said. 

“Net impact: there is one less renter and there is one less rental property. Net impact on the rental market: zero.”

 [Related: Baldwin slams Grattan Institute over negative-gearing claims]

Scrapping negative gearing not on the agenda
lawyersweekly logo
FROM THE WEB
Recommended by Spike Native Network
Listen to other installment of the Real Estate Business Podcast

What is the worst mistake vendors make?

Price too high
Taking low offers too personally
Neglecting curb appeal
Not ‘staging’ the home for sale
Do you have an industry update?
REAL ESTATE BUSINESS NEWSLETTER
Ensure you never miss an issue of the Real Estate Business Bulletin. Enter your email to receive the latest real estate advice and tools to help you sell.