You have 0 free articles left this month.
Register for a free account to access unlimited free content.

Behind NSW’s shock underquoting backflip: Why did the government cave?


Emilie Lauer

By Emilie Lauer

17 November 2026 • 5 minute read


for sale sign house mb

NSW has pulled the plug on its $110,000 underquoting crackdown at the eleventh hour, as a property market downturn forced the government to rethink rules that threatened agents and sellers.

NSW has backpedalled on its underquoting laws just hours before they were set to take effect on 17 November 2026, following fierce industry backlash over rules that could penalise agents and sellers for adjusting prices as market conditions shifted.

On Monday 16 November, NSW Premier Chris Minns said agents in his electorate raised concerns that the reforms could prevent agents and sellers from reducing advertised prices to reflect market conditions, even when a property failed to attract buyer interest.

 
 

Minns also told reporters that the current housing downturn, which has seen property prices drop by 9.4 per cent in the last 12 months to October, brought circumstances not anticipated when the laws were introduced.

“It’s not the seller or the agent’s fault if the price of real estate is dropping,” he said.

“The legislation, at least intuitively, believed that the prices would always rise.

“Well, that may not be the case.”

The ABC reported that the Premier had moved to halt the change by Monday evening, only hours before its scheduled commencement.

It is believed that the new underquoting reforms will now be paused for up to 12 months.

The last-minute decision stemmed from harsh industry criticism, warning that the reforms could disadvantage sellers by preventing agents from advertising below a previously rejected offer.

Additionally, restricting price adjustments was flagged as potentially shutting out buyers who could otherwise afford the property.

The reforms, which passed in June, would have required NSW agents to display a sale price or price range in property advertisements, effectively banning “price on inquiry”.

Agents would also have been obligated to base initial and revised price estimates on the three most comparable recent sales and amend advertising within one business day of changing an estimate.

The changes also included a significant increase in underquoting penalties, lifting the maximum fine from $22,000 to $110,000 or three times an agent’s commission, whichever amount was higher.

Contacted by REB, Minister for Better Regulation and Fair Trading Anoulack Chanthivong said the changes were designed to stamp out underquoting, prevent buyers from being misled and strengthen transparency for both buyers and sellers.

“Parliament passed these laws at a different time and in a different economic and housing market,” Chanthivong told REB.

“Since then, we have heard concerns that these laws could have unintended consequences in the current environment.”

He said that with households already under financial pressure, buyer protection measures should not add further obstacles to entering the property market.

“That’s why the government has made the decision not to proceed with the implementation of these changes today.”

Chanthivong said the watchdog would now work with consumer groups and industry representatives to refine the changes, ensuring the new safeguards protected buyers without creating barriers to home ownership.

Flagged but not listened to

According to Real Estate Institute of NSW (REINSW) CEO Tim McKibbin, today’s regulatory change was unforeseen and has taken agents by surprise, as the industry had been preparing for it.

He said the industry had expected the reforms to commence as scheduled, prompting the institute and agents across NSW to devote significant time and resources over the past month to preparing for the new compliance requirements.

“Whilst we’re thrilled that the Premier saw fit to delay or defer the implementation of this, it is a concern that we have a government that is erratic. Governments should be stable,” McKibbin told REB.

“You’ve got the Premier having to override the minister at the very last time, at the very last date to stop the damage that would’ve been created by this regulation.”

McKibbin said that while the peak body had been involved in the consultations, the minister had refused to meet with them, despite multiple attempts to engage in dialogue.

“We are at the coalface of the industry. So I think in the interest of the people of NSW, property consumers, they would expect the minister to at least listen to us.”

McKibbin argued the government had overstated underquoting, pointing to fewer complaints during market downturns than during periods of rapid price growth.

He said that while successive NSW governments had spent 26 years announcing tougher penalties and expanded consumer protections, they had failed to resolve underquoting and that genuine collaboration with agents was needed instead.

“I think that [the reforms] need to go back on the table. Everything needs to go back on the table. We have underquoting laws that are active now, which came through the last time we had these reforms.

“It goes down to such granular level that an agent cannot say to a purchaser, the vendor is looking for offers over or offers above. It is so prescriptive that agents spend so much time on compliance that it interferes with serving the best interests of their clients.

“The fundamental issue that I think we have in government is that government does not view the vendor as a consumer and that needs to change as a first,” McKibbin said.

Real Estate BusinessWant to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make Real Estate Business a preferred news source on Google.