You have 0 free articles left this month.
Register for a free account to access unlimited free content.

‘Losing listings without even knowing it’: 38k-agent audit exposes costly blind spot


Mathew Williams

By Mathew Williams

16 November 2026 • 5 minute read


young agent computer reb

An analysis of more than 38,000 property professionals has revealed that up to 80 per cent are failing to make the most of their online profiles, potentially handing valuable listings to competitors before they even get a chance to pitch. An industry expert warns AI search is making the problem worse.

Real estate agents could be losing lucrative listings without even knowing they were in contention, with a major industry analysis exposing widespread shortcomings in how agents attract prospective vendors online.

Properti founder and CEO Craig Deveson said agents were increasingly losing ground to digitally savvy competitors, with Google and AI-powered search changing how prospective vendors find and shortlist agents.

 
 

“You could lose the listing before the appraisal,” Deveson said.

Deveson said an analysis of more than 38,000 agents found that, on a 1–100 visibility scale, the average score was just 46.

He said that, of the cohort, between 20 and 25 per cent had developed profiles that added value to their business.

“That leaves an enormous amount of room for agents to step up and enter this world in a better way, provide customers with better information and not miss out on the appraisal,” Deveson said.

“Because when people research agents online, they contact the ones that feel more relevant and invite them in to do a presentation.”

While building a broader social media audience was important for generating listings, Deveson said agents should remember to prioritise their local market.

By focusing on a few key markets, dictated by suburb, asset type, or potential buyers, Deveson said agents could build an identity as an expert in their chosen arena and reap Google and AI search benefits.

“It’s so important to specialise in one or two suburbs and not spread yourself too thinly.”

He said a strong online presence requires understanding how customers search for agents online, and how to position themselves for when the market accelerates again.

Finding footing on the right platforms

Deveson said it was vital for agents to be visible across the full spectrum of social media to create more opportunities to win listings.

He said visibility should extend beyond the typical platforms of Google Business and various social media sites, and that being found by AI search is now an important part of digital branding.

According to Deveson, the ideal timeframe for agents to post and update their profiles was weekly, and he encouraged doing so at least monthly.

He said that to truly cement their position in AI search, agents needed to cultivate a presence on websites and accounts that weren’t entirely their own.

“It’s now that third-party sites are more important than your website,” he said.

“These AI search engines believe that your site might be biased, so they are looking for information on other sites, putting all that together and providing a recommendation.”

Importantly, Deveson said agents need to understand the difference between a high-quality backlink, such as from a media publication, and the rest.

“Paying for low-quality links is a waste of time,” he said.

To make the most of the opportunity to be found in AI search, Deveson said agents should encourage customers to leave reviews as additional proof of quality.

Deveson said agents needed to be comfortable asking customers to leave reviews and suggested adding it to their regular process.

He said there was no quick fix for agents to increase their visibility, and it would require consistency to see the desired results.

“There’s no quick fix. If you act consistently, your profile will increase over time, and you’ll get a larger share of online visibility.”

Positioning ahead of the competition

He said organic content is a valuable source of online engagement, but agencies need to balance it with paid content to maximise their reach and set themselves up for success.

“We’re seeing across our customer base that the ad spend is holding up very well because the better offices and agents are continuing to market, knowing that they won’t be able to bring the buyers in without it.”

“So the ones that don’t do it will fall behind.”

Additionally, Deveson said that agents who had laid the foundation in a harder market would reap the benefits once the cycle changed.

He said a strong digital presence would be a significant benefit for agents, particularly in a harsh property market, putting them on the front foot when the market begins to turn.

“It’s setting yourself up for the new year, and things will probably start to even out at some stage.”

Listen to the full episode here.

Real Estate BusinessWant to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make Real Estate Business a preferred news source on Google.