Powered by MOMENTUM MEDIA
realestatebusiness logo

Breaking news and updates daily. Subscribe to our Newsletter!

Home of the REB Top 100 Agents
Breaking news and updates daily. Subscribe to our newsletter

Website Notifications

Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.

The problem with valuations

By Andrew Littleford
16 January 2015 | 1 minute read

If I was asked what the single most influential element was that defines the success of a loan application, the answer would undoubtedly be the valuation.

Frustration will arise from time to time when the borrower's expectation is at odds with the valuer's. So why does this happen?

Personal attachment

Advertisement
Advertisement

In most instances, the borrower's home is their most valuable asset and it defines their net worth – and if you live in Sydney or Melbourne their dinner conversation! There's a seemingly impenetrable view that houses will always go up in value; this strange concept seemed to prevail even during the GFC, despite overwhelming evidence to the contrary, and thanks to the plethora of reality shows the questionable impact that home improvements have (regardless how minor) on the improved value of a property.

The broker

Completing the application, the borrower will be asked for their estimate of the property's value. This subjective and often inflated figure will mostly go unchallenged. Likely, too, the broker will have not inspected the property or be familiar with the location, so this unvetted figure will be passed to the lender.

Enter the valuer

This is the first occasion where a little science and objectivity is introduced into the equation. Checking title details, land sizes and most of all four or more comparables will create a picture that has substance. But hang on – don't lenders always instruct their valuers to go in conservative or value as a mortgagee sale? Over the years, I would have instructed literally thousands of valuations and most of those for second mortgage transactions. My general rule would be: give me a price that this property would sell for with a comprehensive marketing program in, say, 90 days.

So what does all this mean?

Well, a little bit of research over our last 50 transactions showed the following: 83 per cent of the valuations came in at around 90 per cent of the client's estimate of value (new purchases not included); 15 per cent at 5 per cent or less of the estimate; and the remaining 2 per cent either on the money or a fraction over.

So a couple of things to keep in mind:

• the borrower is pathologically driven to drive his property value estimate up

• if it's a borderline deal, the broker should take this factor into consideration and apply some degree of 'shading'

• valuers are not demons and deal killers

• a real estate agent's appraisal is probably only worth the paper it is written on

The problem with valuations
ANDREW L
lawyersweekly logo

Tags:

ABOUT THE AUTHOR


Andrew  Littleford

Andrew Littleford

Andrew Littleford is a recognised leader within the short-term finance industry.

As the director of the established short-term lender, Interim Finance, Andrew heads a team that’s committed to providing purpose-specific lending solutions nationwide. The company is known for its best-in-market rates and seamless back-end support that ensures compliancy. As a professional lender with over 20 years in the sector, the company prides itself on its transparency, solution-focused and relationship-driven approach.

Rankings
rankings
JUST RELEASED
May 09, 2022

REB Top 50 Women in Real Estate 2022

REB is thrilled to present the Top 50 Women in Real Estate 2022 ranking, which sets t ... LEARN MORE

rankings
JUST RELEASED
May 04, 2022

REB Top 100 Agents 2022

Now in its second decade, the REB Top 100 Agents 2022 rankings are the most revered s ... LEARN MORE

rankings
JUST RELEASED
May 02, 2022

REB Top 50 Agents NSW 2022

Even a pandemic has not put the brakes on the unstoppable property market in NSW, whi ... LEARN MORE

rankings
JUST RELEASED
April 27, 2022

REB Top 50 Agents VIC 2022

The COVID-19 crisis has not deterred the property market in Victoria, which has been ... LEARN MORE

rankings
JUST RELEASED
April 25, 2022

REB Top 50 Agents QLD 2022

As the property market continues to roar in Brisbane and Queensland, the REB Top 50 A ... LEARN MORE

Coming up

rankings rankings
Do you have an industry update?

top suburbs

12 month growth
Mirador
103.33%
Bawley Point
98.13%
Walla Walla
90.7%
Byron Bay
86.67%
Kiama Heights
85.93%
Greta
84.14%
Nulkaba
81%
South Hobart
78.78%
Diddillibah
76.25%
Lennox Head
73.98%
SEE AREA REPORTS ON SMART PROPERTY INVESTMENT WEBSITE
Subscribe to Newsletter

Ensure you never miss an issue of the Real Estate Business Bulletin.
Enter your email to receive the latest real estate advice and tools to help you sell.