realestatebusiness logo

Stay connected. Subscribe to our Newsletter!

Website Notifications

Get notifications in real-time for staying up to date with content that matters to you.

rpm logo latest

Don’t blame PMs for everything, court decides

By Nick Bendel & Elyse Perrau
13 February 2015 | 1 minute read

A legal tribunal has ruled that property managers aren’t automatically responsible for accidents that occur on their properties.

Earlier this month the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal dismissed a case against Philip Kouvelis Real Estate after a tree branch from one of its properties fell on a neighbour’s BMW.

The case was instigated by the next-door neighbour, Steven Waldrip, after his car was damaged in 2012.


Arguments then flew back and forth about who was responsible for the damage.

In the end, the tribunal found that Mr Waldrip’s landlord, Hung Nguyen, was guilty of breaching his duty of care, and ordered him to pay $3,755 compensation to Mr Waldrip.

Suzanne Luchetti, who acted as the property manager for Philip Kouvelis Real Estate, told the tribunal that inspections were carried out every six months and inspection reports were prepared.

“As part of the inspection the property manager would look inside and outside the property, including the trees around the perimeters and the gutters of the house,” the tribunal heard.

“If work was needed it would be noted; the owners’ approval to do the work would be sought and, on approval, [Philip Kouvelis Real Estate] would send out a work order to the relevant business.”

It was an unfortunate coincidence that Mr Waldrip’s car was on the street when the branch fell.

The BMW would normally have been parked in Mr Waldrip's carport. However, while he was overseas, his landlord moved the car onto the street so he could complete some renovations.

Mr Waldrip filed a civil dispute application against Philip Kouvelis Real Estate.

The agency responded in June 2014, “denying each and every allegation of nuisance and negligence set out in the application”, according to the tribunal.

The tribunal said Mr Waldrip later amended the application to include his landlord, Mr Nguyen, saying he breached his duty of care by “parking the car under the overhanging branches of a tree he knew had dropped a branch previously”.

Mr Nguyen filed a response in August 2014 to dispute the claim. However, the tribunal found him guilty and ordered him to compensate Mr Waldrip by 3 March 2015.


Don’t blame PMs for everything, court decides
lawyersweekly logo


Have you experienced sexual harassment or bullying in the workplace?

Yes, I've been the victim of sexual harassment
Yes, I've been the victim of workplace bullying

Total votes: 19
The voting for this poll has ended on: April 30, 2020

Subscribe to our RPM
mailing list


Do you have an industry update?
Subscribe to Newsletter

Ensure you never miss an issue of the Real Estate Business Bulletin.
Enter your email to receive the latest real estate advice and tools to help you sell.